Peter Shalulile gave the hosts the lead in the 57th minute, but Sello Motsepe’s own-goal a few minutes later took the match into extra-time and eventually penalties.
Elsewhere Glad Africa Championship sides Real Kings and TS Sporting also progressed to the quarter-finals following victories over Mbombela United and Happy Wanderers respectively.
Diego Brown’s stoppage-time strike sealed the win for Kings while Sporting edged fellow National First Divison side Mbombela in a penalty shootout.
Twitter erupted with reactions from around the country following the Lions of the North’s victory over Amakhosi.
— Mr Universe 2019 (@Ayabonga_Kekana) February 22, 2020
— #Conspi_theories🇿🇦 (@bombay_m) February 22, 2020
— ❤❤ShazzBucsCelona❤❤ (@NtsoakiChapole) February 22, 2020
— 📢Journey Single Droping Soon 🙏 (@Sir_PabloRSA) February 22, 2020
— Warthog (@Kolobe07) February 22, 2020
Middendorp is sabotaging chiefs with his favoritism! There is absolutely no need to play Parker! The last game Parker started we drew with leopards and today the same story and he didn’t even finish both games! #NedbankCup2020 #Amakhosi4Life 😠😠😠
— ActorVist (@mashoodoZ) February 22, 2020
— Mazola J. Molefe (@superjourno) February 22, 2020
— KonkaTion _ sepoko SA kwaito (@MorekhureTshepo) February 22, 2020
We want Cripple Khune next week pic.twitter.com/kaG30ljNWb
— Vusi Mphazima⏺️ (@vusi_sa) February 22, 2020
George Maluleka and Khama Billiat both missed their penalties. pic.twitter.com/cP3rsVDhNH
— SuperSport 🏆 (@SuperSportTV) February 22, 2020
If I had a boyfriend that supports Kaizer Chiefs we were going to console each other with alcohol within cuddles and some kisses in between, but they don’t want me😭💔 pic.twitter.com/mYffsxNSTB
— Zwanga 👑🌻 (@missZwanga) February 22, 2020
⏱ 120 | FULL-TIME ‼️
We go to the Last 8 after a stubborn Happy Wanderers. What a game. Congratulations to Happy Wanderers what a team, what a fighting spirit.
H. Wanderers 3️⃣ – 4️⃣ TS Sporting
— TS SPORTING FC (@TSSportingFC) February 22, 2020
— Kgaogelo (@Kgaogel28653727) February 22, 2020
— Sbonelo Ncwane (@SboneloNcwane) February 22, 2020
We sent Musa “Thuma Mina” Nyathama to spoil the show. Job well done.
May 2020 is still far.
— Roṋewa Mathephe (@Ronewa_Mathephe) February 22, 2020
— EFF Is The Future (@zen_hap) February 22, 2020
@alfavina , we as faithful supporters appreciate the effort by the team today, however we are very much concerned of the predictable free kick or sat pieces style of play. The other teams seems to have mastered our style of play, the league race is a worrying factor.🙈
— Manic (@risunamanic) February 22, 2020
— OptaJabu (@OptaJabu) February 22, 2020
Chiefs were robbed…
Let’s not argue about but take it as fact🤐
— Mathews_mpete (@MathewsMpete) February 22, 2020
Kaizer Chiefs are out of the Nedbank Cup!! Highlands Park send them crashing out on penalties in Tembisa. Coach Ernst Middendorp now only has the league to rescue this season for club boss Kaizer Motaung on the 50th celebration year on the founding of this club …..
— Mninawa Ntloko (@ntlokom) February 22, 2020